Ashy soap - according to Walton Feed, The soda ash just needs to be rinsed off.
Well , my husband tried my "shave soap" and quickly tell me it was like shaving with soap. Nice. So the heaping tablespoon of clay wasn't enough to call it a shave soap. I also tried it in the shower and shaved my tender legs with it. It foamed beautifully, but 'tis true - it din't feel any different than a regular soap.
I am not wild about them being unscented because I don't think many people would enjoy that smell. There IS a smell to my unscented soap. When a recipe isn't great, gifting them doesn't seem an option.
Ah, I will power smell the next one and make it colorful. I have plans...